Skip to main content
The Incentives Lab
HBT-COG-0496 · Dimension COG · Cognition

No True Scotsman

Redefining a category to exclude counterexamples.

Definition Fallacy·Logical Fallacy·Grade B·stub· enriching…

Scientific Definition

Redefining a category to exclude counterexamples.

Plain-English Definition

Redefining a category to exclude counterexamples.

Feynman Explanation

'No real leader would resist AI.' — said the leader resisting nuance.

Core Principle

Redefining a category to exclude counterexamples.

Mechanisms

Psychological

Redefining a category to exclude counterexamples.

Behavioral Economic

Pending editorial review.

Neurological

Pending editorial review.

Evolutionary

Pending editorial review.

Sociological

Pending editorial review.

Computational

Pending editorial review.

Systems

Pending editorial review.

Inputs (Triggers)

Pending editorial review.

Outputs (Behaviors)

Pending editorial review.

Behavioral Signature

'No real leader would resist AI.' — said the leader resisting nuance.

Examples

Everyday
  • Dismissing dissent by reclassifying dissenters as not real practitioners.
Modern (Organizational)
  • Critical feedback escaped by redefinition.
Historical

Pending editorial review.

Famous Experiments

Pending editorial review.

Design Principles

Pending editorial review.

Measurement Approaches

Pending editorial review.

Evidence

Evidence Grade
B (A strongest → E speculative)
Replication
★★★☆☆
Intervention Confidence
3 / 5
Consensus
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Limitations
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Open Research Questions

Pending editorial review.

Primary References

Pending editorial review.

Signature Section

The Perverse Incentive Lens™

How this behavior is exploited — and how to redesign around it.

Exploitation
Critical feedback escaped by redefinition.
Amplifying Incentives
Critical feedback escaped by redefinition.
Org Failure Modes
Critical feedback escaped by redefinition.
Societal Failure Modes
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Ethical Considerations
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Redesign Strategies
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Diagnostic Questions

Pending editorial review.

Warning Signs

Pending editorial review.

Red Flags

Pending editorial review.

Intervention Playbook
Individual
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Team
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Organization
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Policy
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
AI Implications
Detection
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Measurement
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Mitigation
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).
Responsible Use
Pending editorial review (HBT v1.0 auto-seed).

Interactive Mini Network

Click any neighbor to re-center the graph and follow the threads of connection.

HBT-COG-0496 · COG
No True Scotsman
NTBTBegging the QuestionCRCircular ReasoningCFComposition FallacyCFContinuum FallacyDRDefinitional RetreatDFDivision FallacyETEither-Or Trap (more…EFEtymological FallacyFEFalse EquivalenceMGMiddle Ground Fallacy

Knowledge Graph Neighbors

Version History

v1.1.0 · 2026-06-28Initial auto-seed from corpus.